Skip to content
GT Stewart Solicitors Logo

020 8299 6000CONFIDENTIAL ENQUIRY

Secure Enquiry

Contact us and see how our team can help you

    • Home
    • Criminal Defence
      • Investigations
      • Extradition
      • Youth Crime
        • Children & Young persons in the Courts
        • Anti-social Behaviour, Crime & Policing Act 2014 – The Law
        • Criminal Behaviour Orders (CBOs) and Anti-Social Behaviour Injunctions (ASBIs)
      • Sexual Offences
      • Criminal Appeals
      • Motoring Offences
        • Careless Driving
        • Death by Dangerous Driving
        • Dangerous Driving
        • Drink Driving
        • Disqualification – Totting Up (12pts)
        • Driving whilst Disqualified
        • Driving whilst Impaired through Drugs
        • Driving without Insurance
        • Failing to Provide a Specimen
        • Parking Offences
        • Road Rage Offences
        • Speeding Offence
        • Using a Mobile Phone whilst Driving
      • Prison Law
    • Family Law
      • Domestic Abuse
      • Divorce & Seperation
      • Care Proceedings
      • Financial Claims
      • Cohabitation agreements
      • Pre Nuptual Agreements
      • Post Nuptual Agreements
      • Civil Partnerships
      • Adoption & Surrogacy
    • Protecting Your Rights
      • Action against the Police
      • Social Welfare
      • Mental Health
      • Court of Protection
      • Public Law
    • Housing
      • Anti Social Behaviour
      • Homelessness
      • Disrepair
      • Defending Possession Claims
      • Landlord Advice
    • News & Media
    • UK Offices
      • Ashford
      • Birmingham
      • City of London
      • Croydon
      • Dartford
      • East Dulwich
      • Hammersmith
      • Leeds
      • Manchester
    • About us
      • Our People
      • Mission Statement
      • Testimonials and Feedback
      • Careers with us
      • Work experience & internships
      • Equality and Diversity
      • Privacy Policy
    • Contact us
      • Contact us
      • Submit feedback
      • Confidential Enquiry
      • Complaints Procedure
    • Home
    • Criminal Defence
      • Investigations
      • Extradition
      • Youth Crime
        • Children & Young persons in the Courts
        • Anti-social Behaviour, Crime & Policing Act 2014 – The Law
        • Criminal Behaviour Orders (CBOs) and Anti-Social Behaviour Injunctions (ASBIs)
      • Sexual Offences
      • Criminal Appeals
      • Motoring Offences
        • Careless Driving
        • Death by Dangerous Driving
        • Dangerous Driving
        • Drink Driving
        • Disqualification – Totting Up (12pts)
        • Driving whilst Disqualified
        • Driving whilst Impaired through Drugs
        • Driving without Insurance
        • Failing to Provide a Specimen
        • Parking Offences
        • Road Rage Offences
        • Speeding Offence
        • Using a Mobile Phone whilst Driving
      • Prison Law
    • Family Law
      • Domestic Abuse
      • Divorce & Seperation
      • Care Proceedings
      • Financial Claims
      • Cohabitation agreements
      • Pre Nuptual Agreements
      • Post Nuptual Agreements
      • Civil Partnerships
      • Adoption & Surrogacy
    • Protecting Your Rights
      • Action against the Police
      • Social Welfare
      • Mental Health
      • Court of Protection
      • Public Law
    • Housing
      • Anti Social Behaviour
      • Homelessness
      • Disrepair
      • Defending Possession Claims
      • Landlord Advice
    • News & Media
    • UK Offices
      • Ashford
      • Birmingham
      • City of London
      • Croydon
      • Dartford
      • East Dulwich
      • Hammersmith
      • Leeds
      • Manchester
    • About us
      • Our People
      • Mission Statement
      • Testimonials and Feedback
      • Careers with us
      • Work experience & internships
      • Equality and Diversity
      • Privacy Policy
    • Contact us
      • Contact us
      • Submit feedback
      • Confidential Enquiry
      • Complaints Procedure
    Loading...
    • “Professional, sincere…compassionate and empathetic. I'm incredibly grateful to you for taking on my case.”

      Housing Law Client

      What our clients say

    Home>JR success for GT Stewart’s Appeals & Reviews Team

    JR success for GT Stewart’s Appeals & Reviews Team

    This week the Legal Aid Agency (LAA) agreed to reverse their original refusal to grant a higher rate for instructing a QC on an ongoing appeal case.

    GT Stewart had been arguing for 18 months that an ongoing appeal case merited the use of a QC at the normal higher hourly rate to reflect the exceptional nature of the case. They pointed out to the LAA they had misapplied their internal guidance and that was repeated by the Independent Costs Assessor who failed to apply the test assessing what is ‘exceptional’ set out in R v The Legal Aid Board ex parte RM Broudie & Co [1994].

    The LAA and the ICA agreed the case was exceptional in many ways but argued that it was not sufficiently so to justify a higher hourly rate. They pointed out many cases of murder were complicated. This misapplied the Broudie test which requires the notional comparison to be with the generality of criminal cases not murder cases as that would mean it would have to exceptional for an already exceptional case – quite a high, if not impossible bar to clear as pointed out in Broudie by Rose LJ.

    The paper application came before Ouseley J who queried the rationale of the LAA’s approach. The claim was due for a hearing this week and on further reflection the Ministry of Justice legal department intervened and agreed to reverse the LAA’s earlier decision and pay the Claimant’s reasonable legal costs of the challenge.

    The case was handled by Greg Stewart assisted by Katie Knafler and Rachel Pain from our specialist Appeals & Reviews team. The instructed advocate was Lindsay Johnson from Doughty Street Chambers.

    This was an important challenge to establish that the higher hourly rate paid to external advocates in exceptional cases should continue in Criminal Appeals & Reviews cases as it had before.

    By GT Stewart Admin|2021-01-29T09:57:12+00:00January 29th, 2021|Criminal Defence, News|

    Share this page!

    FacebookTwitterLinkedInWhatsAppEmail
    children law accredited logo
    criminal-litigation-accredited logo
    mental-health logo
    resolution-first-for-family-law logo
    lexcel-legal-practice-quality-mark logo
    LAPG member
    GT Stewart Solicitors Logo

    © 2020 | GT Stewart Solicitors & Advocates

    GT Stewart Ltd | Registered office: 2a Melbourne Grove, East Dulwich, London, SE22 8PL | Registered no. 07529550
    Authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority no.633578 VAT no. 248707088

    Legal Website Development
    TwitterLinkedInFacebook
    Search
    GT Stewart Solicitors
    • Home
    • Criminal Defence
      • Investigations
      • Extradition
      • Youth Crime
        • Children & Young persons in the Courts
        • Anti-social Behaviour, Crime & Policing Act 2014 – The Law
        • Criminal Behaviour Orders (CBOs) and Anti-Social Behaviour Injunctions (ASBIs)
      • Sexual Offences
      • Criminal Appeals
      • Motoring Offences
        • Careless Driving
        • Death by Dangerous Driving
        • Dangerous Driving
        • Drink Driving
        • Disqualification – Totting Up (12pts)
        • Driving whilst Disqualified
        • Driving whilst Impaired through Drugs
        • Driving without Insurance
        • Failing to Provide a Specimen
        • Parking Offences
        • Road Rage Offences
        • Speeding Offence
        • Using a Mobile Phone whilst Driving
      • Prison Law
    • Family Law
      • Domestic Abuse
      • Divorce & Seperation
      • Care Proceedings
      • Financial Claims
      • Cohabitation agreements
      • Pre Nuptual Agreements
      • Post Nuptual Agreements
      • Civil Partnerships
      • Adoption & Surrogacy
    • Protecting Your Rights
      • Action against the Police
      • Social Welfare
      • Mental Health
      • Court of Protection
      • Public Law
    • Housing
      • Anti Social Behaviour
      • Homelessness
      • Disrepair
      • Defending Possession Claims
      • Landlord Advice
    • News & Media
    • UK Offices
      • Ashford
      • Birmingham
      • City of London
      • Croydon
      • Dartford
      • East Dulwich
      • Hammersmith
      • Leeds
      • Manchester
    • About us
      • Our People
      • Mission Statement
      • Testimonials and Feedback
      • Careers with us
      • Work experience & internships
      • Equality and Diversity
      • Privacy Policy
    • Contact us
      • Contact us
      • Submit feedback
      • Confidential Enquiry
      • Complaints Procedure
    This website uses cookies and third party services. By continuing to use the site or clicking 'OK' you accept. OK