Skip to content
GT Stewart Solicitors Logo

020 8299 6000CONFIDENTIAL ENQUIRY

Secure Enquiry

Contact us and see how our team can help you

    • Home
    • Criminal Defence
      • Investigations
      • Extradition
      • Youth Crime
        • Children & Young persons in the Courts
        • Anti-social Behaviour, Crime & Policing Act 2014 – The Law
        • Criminal Behaviour Orders (CBOs) and Anti-Social Behaviour Injunctions (ASBIs)
      • Sexual Offences
      • Criminal Appeals
      • Motoring Offences
        • Careless Driving
        • Death by Dangerous Driving
        • Dangerous Driving
        • Drink Driving
        • Disqualification – Totting Up (12pts)
        • Driving whilst Disqualified
        • Driving whilst Impaired through Drugs
        • Driving without Insurance
        • Failing to Provide a Specimen
        • Parking Offences
        • Road Rage Offences
        • Speeding Offence
        • Using a Mobile Phone whilst Driving
      • Prison Law
    • Family Law
      • Domestic Abuse
      • Divorce & Seperation
      • Care Proceedings
      • Financial Claims
      • Cohabitation agreements
      • Pre Nuptual Agreements
      • Post Nuptual Agreements
      • Civil Partnerships
      • Adoption & Surrogacy
    • Protecting Your Rights
      • Action against the Police
      • Social Welfare
      • Mental Health
      • Court of Protection
      • Public Law
      • Education Law
    • Housing
      • Anti Social Behaviour
      • Homelessness
      • Disrepair
      • Defending Possession Claims
      • Landlord Advice
    • News & Media
    • UK Offices
      • Ashford
      • Birmingham
      • City of London
      • Croydon
      • Dartford
      • East Dulwich
      • Hammersmith
      • Leeds
      • Manchester
      • Peterborough
    • About us
      • Our People
      • Mission Statement
      • Testimonials and Feedback
      • Careers with us
      • Work experience & internships
      • Equality and Diversity
      • Privacy Policy
    • Contact us
      • Contact us
      • Submit feedback
      • Confidential Enquiry
      • Complaints Procedure
    • Home
    • Criminal Defence
      • Investigations
      • Extradition
      • Youth Crime
        • Children & Young persons in the Courts
        • Anti-social Behaviour, Crime & Policing Act 2014 – The Law
        • Criminal Behaviour Orders (CBOs) and Anti-Social Behaviour Injunctions (ASBIs)
      • Sexual Offences
      • Criminal Appeals
      • Motoring Offences
        • Careless Driving
        • Death by Dangerous Driving
        • Dangerous Driving
        • Drink Driving
        • Disqualification – Totting Up (12pts)
        • Driving whilst Disqualified
        • Driving whilst Impaired through Drugs
        • Driving without Insurance
        • Failing to Provide a Specimen
        • Parking Offences
        • Road Rage Offences
        • Speeding Offence
        • Using a Mobile Phone whilst Driving
      • Prison Law
    • Family Law
      • Domestic Abuse
      • Divorce & Seperation
      • Care Proceedings
      • Financial Claims
      • Cohabitation agreements
      • Pre Nuptual Agreements
      • Post Nuptual Agreements
      • Civil Partnerships
      • Adoption & Surrogacy
    • Protecting Your Rights
      • Action against the Police
      • Social Welfare
      • Mental Health
      • Court of Protection
      • Public Law
      • Education Law
    • Housing
      • Anti Social Behaviour
      • Homelessness
      • Disrepair
      • Defending Possession Claims
      • Landlord Advice
    • News & Media
    • UK Offices
      • Ashford
      • Birmingham
      • City of London
      • Croydon
      • Dartford
      • East Dulwich
      • Hammersmith
      • Leeds
      • Manchester
      • Peterborough
    • About us
      • Our People
      • Mission Statement
      • Testimonials and Feedback
      • Careers with us
      • Work experience & internships
      • Equality and Diversity
      • Privacy Policy
    • Contact us
      • Contact us
      • Submit feedback
      • Confidential Enquiry
      • Complaints Procedure
    Loading...
    • “Professional, sincere…compassionate and empathetic. I'm incredibly grateful to you for taking on my case.”

      Housing Law Client

      What our clients say

    Home>How do you terminate a flexible tenancy during the fixed term – Part two

    How do you terminate a flexible tenancy during the fixed term – Part two

    A Flexible tenancy is a type of secure tenancy, which is granted for a fixed term of at least two years. Many local authorities grant flexible tenancies for fixed terms of at least five years. At the end of the fixed term, the landlord has a mandatory ground for possession. However, for years, it was not clear how to terminate a flexible tenancy during the fixed term.

    Ms Kalonga was granted a flexible tenancy for a fixed term of five years from 25 May 2015. Croydon LBC considered her to have participated in acts of antisocial behaviour and to have arrears of rent. Croydon LBC obtained an outright possession order. Ms Kalonga then instructed GT Stewart. We successfully appealed against the possession order and it was set aside. We subsequently argued that a flexible tenancy can only be terminated by forfeiture and that Croydon were prevented from doing so as there was no forfeiture clause in Ms Kalonga’s tenancy agreement. In light of the importance of the issue, the possession claim was transferred to the High Court for determination.

    In June 2020, we reported the High Court decision of Croydon LBC v Kalonga which clarified the issue.  The High Court ruled that a flexible tenancy could only be brought to an end during the fixed term if the terms of the tenancy agreement contained a forfeiture clause (or possibly a break clause). Given that Ms Kalonga’s tenancy did not have a forfeiture clause, the possession claim was dismissed.

    We had also argued in the High Court that where the tenancy agreement contained a forfeiture clause, the landlord would have to use the forfeiture procedures.  The landlord would have to serve a notice under s.146, Law of Property Act 1925 in respect of breaches (other than those relating to the non-payment of rent).  Finally, the landlord would have to bring proceedings for an order under s.82(3). The High Court did not agree with Ms Kalonga on this point and held that the landlord did not have to follow a forfeiture-type route to recover possession of the property but could use any of general routes identified in the Housing Act1985 to recover possession of the property.

    Croydon LBC appealed to the Court of Appeal. Ms Kalonga cross-appealed on the issue of which route the landlord should follow to obtain possession where the tenancy agreement contained a forfeiture clause.

    Court of Appeal dismissed the LB Croydon’s appeal, and allowed Ms Kalonga’s cross appeal,  ruling that the only way to terminate a fixed term secure tenancy during the fixed term was if the tenancy agreement contained a forfeiture clause and by obtaining an order for termination under s.82(1A)(b) Housing Act 1985. A copy of the judgement can be found here Croydon LBC v Kalonga [2021] EWCA Civ 77

    There are c.30,000 flexible tenancies in England, the vast majority of which do not contain a forfeiture clause. This decision confers considerable security of tenure on tenants during the fixed term and also presents significant challenges for local authorities.

    Denise Phillips was the solicitor representing Ms Kalonga and Justin Bates of Landmark Chambers led Anneli Robins of 4-5 Gray’s Inn Square in both the High Court and Court of Appeal.

    By GT Stewart Marketing|2021-01-29T11:37:24+00:00January 28th, 2021|Housing Law, News|

    Share this page!

    FacebookTwitterLinkedInWhatsAppEmail
    children law accredited logo
    criminal-litigation-accredited logo
    mental-health logo
    resolution-first-for-family-law logo
    lexcel-legal-practice-quality-mark logo
    GT Stewart Solicitors Logo

    © 2020 | GT Stewart Solicitors & Advocates

    GT Stewart Ltd | Registered office: 2a Melbourne Grove, East Dulwich, London, SE22 8PL | Registered no. 07529550
    Authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority no.633578 VAT no. 248707088

    Legal Website Development
    TwitterLinkedInFacebook
    Search
    GT Stewart Solicitors
    • Home
    • Criminal Defence
      • Investigations
      • Extradition
      • Youth Crime
        • Children & Young persons in the Courts
        • Anti-social Behaviour, Crime & Policing Act 2014 – The Law
        • Criminal Behaviour Orders (CBOs) and Anti-Social Behaviour Injunctions (ASBIs)
      • Sexual Offences
      • Criminal Appeals
      • Motoring Offences
        • Careless Driving
        • Death by Dangerous Driving
        • Dangerous Driving
        • Drink Driving
        • Disqualification – Totting Up (12pts)
        • Driving whilst Disqualified
        • Driving whilst Impaired through Drugs
        • Driving without Insurance
        • Failing to Provide a Specimen
        • Parking Offences
        • Road Rage Offences
        • Speeding Offence
        • Using a Mobile Phone whilst Driving
      • Prison Law
    • Family Law
      • Domestic Abuse
      • Divorce & Seperation
      • Care Proceedings
      • Financial Claims
      • Cohabitation agreements
      • Pre Nuptual Agreements
      • Post Nuptual Agreements
      • Civil Partnerships
      • Adoption & Surrogacy
    • Protecting Your Rights
      • Action against the Police
      • Social Welfare
      • Mental Health
      • Court of Protection
      • Public Law
      • Education Law
    • Housing
      • Anti Social Behaviour
      • Homelessness
      • Disrepair
      • Defending Possession Claims
      • Landlord Advice
    • News & Media
    • UK Offices
      • Ashford
      • Birmingham
      • City of London
      • Croydon
      • Dartford
      • East Dulwich
      • Hammersmith
      • Leeds
      • Manchester
      • Peterborough
    • About us
      • Our People
      • Mission Statement
      • Testimonials and Feedback
      • Careers with us
      • Work experience & internships
      • Equality and Diversity
      • Privacy Policy
    • Contact us
      • Contact us
      • Submit feedback
      • Confidential Enquiry
      • Complaints Procedure
    This website uses cookies and third party services. By continuing to use the site or clicking 'OK' you accept. OK